On the eleventh day of Christmas, my true
love read to me: 11 Birthdays, Ten Big Ones, Nine Parts of Desire, When
Eight Bells Toll, The 7 Habits of
Highly Effective People, The Six
Sacred Stones, Five on a Treasure
Island, The 4-Hour Work Week, Three Wishes, Two Boys Kissing and One Shot
in a pear tree.
Today, for the eleventh day of Christmas,
I’m reviewing 11 Birthdays by Wendy
Mass.
This is a middle grade book with a
Groundhog Day premise. Amanda and Leo were born on the same day in a small-town
hospital, and ever since they’ve celebrated their birthday together. Until, at
their tenth birthday party, Amanda overhears Leo saying something
unforgiveable, and promptly severs their friendship.
Now it’s their eleventh birthday. They’re
both miserable – but worse than that, they’re both caught in a curse that
ensnared their greatgrandparents decades before – and the horrible day of their
eleventh birthday just keeps repeating. If they can’t figure out what’s going
on and how to break their curse, they could be blowing out eleven candles every
day for the rest of their lives.
It’s a long time since I’ve read a middle
grade book, and I have to admit this wasn’t my first choice for the eleventh
read of Christmas. That was Stephen King’s time travel story 11.22.63 – but
when I got to the library and saw the size of that sucker, I went looking for
something that wasn’t going to take me a week to read, and this is what I
found.
I think if I’d read it when I was a middle-grader I would have really
enjoyed this. As an adult I found some of the themes pushed a bit heavily, but
eight or nine-year-old me would never have noticed, too busy following the
amusing adventures of the two birthday kids. I would have liked the little
touch of magic too. What kid wouldn’t love the chance to live without
consequences? No matter what you did, it was all forgotten when you woke up and
relived the same day fresh again. Think of the possibilities! Leo certainly
did.
It was nice to see a proper friendship
between a girl and a boy too. A sweet, feel-good story for the younger readers
in your life.
For the last read of Christmas, coming up
is 12th of Never by James
Patterson and Maxine Paetro.
I was in a children's bookstore one day, looking at the shelves, and a girl standing next to me pulled out 11 Birthdays and said, "I recommend this!" and proceeded to rave about it.
ReplyDeleteIt was a fun book. Glad to see it has fans!
Delete